What Is the best state to form your LLC in?
Typically, your home state is the best choice for forming your LLC because that is where your business primarily operates. However, there are exceptions:
1) Non-US residents can choose any state. Wyoming is often recommended for its privacy protections and lower annual fees compared to states like Delaware ($50/year vs. $300/year).
2) Real estate LLCs may have different considerations. (we’ll talk about it below)
Let’s address some common questions on this topic.
What is a Domestic LLC vs. a Foreign LLC?
LLCs are regulated at the state level. A Domestic LLC is one that is registered and does business in its home state. On the other hand, a Foreign LLC is formed in one state but operates in another.
For example, if you form and operate your LLC in North Carolina, it’s considered a Domestic LLC because it operates within the jurisdiction of that state. However, if you form your LLC in North Carolina but do business in Florida, it becomes a Foreign LLC.
This structure facilitates multi-state operations for businesses without requiring them to form separate LLCs in each state, while also allowing states to collect revenue from businesses operating within their jurisdictions.
Are there any disadvantages to forming a Foreign LLC?
The primary disadvantage of forming a Foreign LLC is the additional financial burden. Operating a foreign LLC often results in double the fees of a domestic LLC.
For example, if you form an LLC in Wyoming but intend to do business in another state, you’ll need to register that Wyoming LLC as a Foreign LLC in your home state. This requires paying two sets of state filing fees, the cost of a registered agent to use their address in the “foreign” state, and annual report fees.
This increased complexity and cost can strain your finances, complicate administrative tasks, and increase the likelihood of oversight in reporting activities.
What Happens if You Don’t Report Your Business Activity?
Failure to register your business as a foreign entity in your home state when forming a foreign LLC, or attempting to avoid paying your full tax liability, can result in severe consequences.
These consequences may include:
- Fines ranging from a few hundred to several thousand dollars
- Penalties imposed by regulatory authorities
- Interest accrued on unpaid taxes
- Legal fees associated with litigation
- Restrictions placed on your business activities
It’s not advisable to fail to register as a foreign LLC in another state where you do business. For example, Connecticut collected $1.3 million in fines from unregistered businesses in 2018, with an average penalty of $4,600. Given the significant financial implications, it’s important to ensure that you’re in compliance with the law.
Business Tax Implications: Paying Taxes Where You Earn
Determining whether you need to register as a foreign LLC in states other than your home state boils down to where your income comes from. If a significant portion of your income comes from another state, it’s imperative that you register there and report that income accordingly. Given the complexities involved, especially for multi-state businesses, it is advisable to consult an accountant to ensure compliance.
Some states have earned a reputation as “magic states,” purportedly offering more favorable registration conditions. But is this perception true?
Home State vs. “Special State”
Wyoming, Delaware and other states such as Nevada have gained recognition among business owners for offering unique benefits to foreign LLCs registered there.
While there are indeed some advantages, it’s unlikely that these advantages will apply to LLCs operating outside of the respective states themselves.
Wyoming
Wyoming offers enticing benefits such as low tax rates, including no income or franchise taxes, and an annual filing fee of just $50. In addition, its sales tax rate is below the national average at only 4%.
In addition, Wyoming offers enhanced privacy protection by allowing LLC owners to maintain anonymity in public records, a feature uncommon in other states. This level of privacy is beneficial for business owners who wish to keep a low profile or avoid associating their names with their business activities.
Delaware
In addition to Wyoming’s enhanced privacy protections, Delaware offers superior legal protections compared to other states. Delaware operates the Delaware Court of Chancery, a specialized system tailored to corporate legal matters. Specifically, corporate cases are decided without a jury, making the process much more favorable to businesses.
Non-US Citizens and Non-US Residents: What Should You Do?
You don’t have to be a U.S. citizen or resident to form an LLC, and you have the freedom to choose any state for its formation.
The choice of state usually depends on the operational structure of your business. If you plan to have a physical location with employees, it’s advisable to form your LLC in the state where your business will operate. For example, if you’re expanding a successful chain of salons from Canada into Washington State, you should form your LLC in Washington.
Alternatively, if your business will operate in the U.S. without a physical presence, you have the flexibility to choose any state for your LLC formation. However, the process for obtaining an Employer Identification Number (EIN) or setting up a bank account may vary, and there may be additional IRS filing requirements.
Your federal and state tax obligations will also depend on your business’s unique circumstances and revenue sources.
The Best State to Form an LLC for an Online Business
For those conducting business online with a customer base that spans the country or the world, the choice of state for forming an LLC becomes critical.
If your business operates entirely over the Internet and draws customers from multiple states or countries, your home state remains the optimal choice for LLC formation. Since your online operations likely originate from your home or a nearby location, this is where the core business transactions occur, making it the most relevant jurisdiction.
However, for individuals with a nomadic lifestyle or a business without a fixed location, it is advisable to choose the state with the strongest personal ties. Factors such as primary residence, family location, driver’s license registration, or tax obligations can guide your decision. By aligning your LLC formation with your primary personal ties, you ensure practicality and compliance with legal requirements.
Where Should I Register a Real Estate LLC?
As mentioned above, the rules are different when forming an LLC for a real estate business.
For real estate-focused LLCs, the traditional “home state rule” may not always apply. Typically, real estate business activities and income generated remain localized in the state where the real estate is located. Therefore, to minimize expenses, it’s wise to form your LLC in the state(s) where your real estate is located.
For example, suppose you are a resident of Pennsylvania but own rental property in New York. Since all of your relevant business activities will take place in New York, it’s wise to form your LLC there. This approach allows you to consolidate costs, including formation fees, state income taxes, and maintenance fees, within a single state.
If you’re an investor planning to hold multiple properties in different states under one LLC (although some opt for separate entities for each investment), be sure to register a foreign LLC in each state where you own property to stay compliant and streamline administrative processes.
Overall Recommendation
Forming an LLC in your home state (a Domestic LLC) is generally less expensive and simpler than forming a Foreign LLC, providing long-term benefits for your business. Unless you are a non-U.S. citizen or resident (in which case Wyoming is recommended), or your LLC is focused on real estate, it’s advisable to form your LLC in your home state to avoid potentially high fees. Make sure you comply with the legal requirements of any other state in which you do business by forming the appropriate legal entity as required. Ultimately, the decision is yours – it’s your business, your choice!
Keep in mind that Startxpress team is always here to start your US company whenever you want!
For more details, check out the Startxpress Help Center and Blog. If you need assistance, contact us at support@startxpress.io! We’re here to help make managing your business as smooth as possible.
Related Articles
- What is an EIN?
- State by State Annual Report Fees
- Annual Report Filling Guide
- A State by State Guide of LLC Fees
- Do I need an ITIN to apply for a credit card?
Was this helpful?
0 / 0