Should you incorporate your LLC in Delaware or Wyoming?
So you’ve decided that a Limited Liability Company (LLC) is the best structure for your new business. The next big challenge is choosing the optimal state in which to form your LLC. Choosing the right state is a frequently misunderstood aspect of starting a new business and can be confusing even for experienced business owners.
To help you make the best choice and set your business up for success, we outline the key questions to consider and consult with your legal and financial advisors. We also break down the key advantages of popular “business friendly” states such as Delaware and Wyoming.
Where should you incorporate your business?
When deciding which state is best for your LLC, many factors can influence your decision. First and foremost, you’ll need to consider the specific goals and needs of your business.
It’s common to hear from new business owners who are frustrated because their LLC was formed in the “wrong state,” resulting in unnecessary costs, fees, taxes, paperwork and complications.
Additionally, the process of re-domesticating an LLC to another state can be troublesome, often requiring the closure and reopening of bank accounts, redrafting of agreements, and updating the IRS, among other tasks.
To help you avoid these pitfalls in the first place, we outline the key questions you should consider when deciding where to form your LLC.
What’s your home state?
Business owners can choose to file their LLC in the state where their business operates or in a different state.
In most cases, if the business owner lives in the same state as the business’s physical and operational location, it is most practical to form the LLC in their home state.
Setting up a domestic LLC offers several key advantages. Firstly, you avoid the additional cost of paying a registered agent to represent you in another state. Secondly, you avoid the extra step of registering a foreign LLC in your home state.
If you choose to set up an LLC in a different state, you may need to file a foreign LLC in your home state, effectively doubling your fees and filing obligations to meet the requirements of both states.
For this reason, many small business owners opt to register their LLC in the state where they plan to do business.
However, if your business does not have a physical location or you intend to conduct most of your business outside your home state, it might be worthwhile to consider filing your LLC in one of the ‘business-friendly’ states.
What size business are you hoping to grow?
You also need to consider the future growth goals of your business. An LLC that starts with a single member and manager may expand significantly over the years, with members spread across the country. How big do you expect your business to be in five years? Do you plan to have foreign members or members in multiple states?
If your business is poised for high growth, it may make more sense to incorporate in a “business friendly” state such as Delaware. This can be advantageous if you outgrow the LLC structure and wish to convert to a corporation, or if you decide to seek venture funding.
What are your industry regulations?
Are there industry-specific regulations that could influence where you should register your LLC? For instance, if your business involves registering vehicles with the Department of Transportation, it might be best to form your LLC in your home state to avoid the risk of your application being denied because you are not a resident of your LLC’s state. Be sure to research the relevant rules and regulations or seek guidance from knowledgeable legal professionals to ensure compliance.
‘Business-friendly’ States,
Delaware and Wyoming are renowned for being business-friendly states due to their pro-business laws and low corporate income taxes. Both states offer a streamlined filing process, making it quick and easy to register an LLC with minimal costs and paperwork.
Delaware is internationally recognized as the preferred U.S. state for LLC registration and incorporation, home to over 50% of all U.S. publicly traded companies and about 63% of Fortune 500 companies. Wyoming, on the other hand, is rapidly gaining a reputation as an excellent place to start a small business, with the Economist magazine even dubbing it the “Switzerland of the Rocky Mountains.”
While both states offer a balanced and flexible regime for business registration, as well as asset and liability protection, they are not a universal one-size-fits-all solution. The two states differ in fees, taxes, laws, and requirements. The needs of a large, high-growth, high-risk LLC can be vastly different from those of a small business with limited growth and risk. Therefore, it is crucial to weigh all options carefully when deciding on the right state for your LLC.
Advantages of a Delaware LLC
There are many reasons why Delaware is considered the capital of corporate America. We list some of these below.
Domestic tax haven
Delaware offers several tax advantages that naturally attract large businesses seeking to reduce their tax burden. The state does not impose income tax on businesses that do not operate within Delaware. Instead, these businesses only need to pay the much lower franchise tax, which is a flat fee of $300 for LLCs.
Additionally, Delaware does not levy sales tax, value-added tax, inheritance tax, inventory tax, capital shares or stock transfer tax, or personal property tax (only a relatively low county-level real estate tax).
Furthermore, Delaware does not tax gains from fixed-income or equity investments. This has led to the creation of the so-called “Delaware Loophole,” where businesses that derive a significant portion of their income from intangible assets like patents, trademarks, and copyrights can avoid tax liabilities in other states by designating Delaware as their “home.”
Strong legal precedent
The Delaware Court of Chancery is the oldest and most esteemed business court in the United States. It is renowned for enabling the swift resolution of corporate disputes. While similar disputes might take up to two years to resolve elsewhere, they can be settled within weeks in Delaware. Chancery judges are highly knowledgeable in business law and adept at handling complex corporate issues that can easily perplex juries.
The Court of Chancery’s decisions frequently influence Supreme Court corporate litigation and set the standard for U.S. corporate law. Delaware’s focus on predictability, consistency, and stability has solidified its status as the preferred jurisdiction for business formation.
Privacy
Delaware is one of only four states (along with Wyoming, Nevada, and New Mexico) that does not require the names and addresses of LLC members to be made public. While Delaware mandates that a list of initial members or officers be submitted with the LLC application, only the entity’s name and the registered agent’s address are made public. Although an anonymous LLC may still need to disclose member details to banks and the Internal Revenue Service (IRS), it provides an effective shield against stalkers or malicious individuals seeking personal information. Additionally, it can help protect you from negative public relations in the event of any business-related controversy.
Quick and easy registration
When you file for incorporation, you often want to get your business off the ground as quickly as possible. Whether you have other demands on your time or need to expedite the process for other reasons, Delaware offers a $100 rush fee to speed up the incorporation process. In contrast, Wyoming does not provide this service, making Delaware a better option if time is a critical factor.
Disadvantages of a Delaware LLC
A Delaware LLC offers prestige and advantages, particularly appealing to large, high-risk companies that generate significant income from patents and trademarks. However, the cost of registering and maintaining a Delaware LLC may pose a barrier for smaller business ventures.
Delaware imposes various sharing and reporting requirements, resulting in increased paperwork for corporations, both in their early stages and later on. LLCs are also obligated to fulfill filing requirements, including annual reports. Additionally, Delaware collects corporate income tax information for sharing with the IRS.
For business owners without a legal residence in Delaware, hiring a registered agent with a street address (not just a post office box) in the state becomes necessary, further increasing the associated fees of maintaining an LLC.
Smaller, less risky LLCs may find Wyoming more suitable for their needs.
Advantages of a Wyoming LLC
If you’re considering incorporating a small business or tech startup, Wyoming offers robust asset protection, similar to Delaware. Here are some key benefits of incorporating in Wyoming.
Wyoming “closely held” LLCs are well-suited for family business, estate planning, and asset protection
An often overlooked advantage of Wyoming is the option to establish a ‘Wyoming Close LLC’. Introduced in 2002, the Wyoming Close LLC is a relatively recent addition to the range of available business entities in Wyoming, primarily tailored for small and family businesses. It’s a tightly controlled structure that differs from a regular LLC by allowing for greater restrictions on ownership rights, company interest transfers, membership, withdrawals, resignation, and dissolution.
Membership in a Close LLC is granted only with the unanimous consent of all members, and members cannot leave without unanimous consent. Additionally, no member is entitled to the return of their initial contribution. These features make Close LLCs ideal for passing down businesses from one generation to the next, making them a top choice for small family businesses and a valuable tool in estate planning.
Moreover, Wyoming Close LLCs offer some of the strongest asset protection available in the country. The primary remedy a creditor has against a Wyoming Close LLC is a charging order. Even if a charging order is granted, creditors can only receive payment if the Close LLC distributes funds. If no distributions occur, the creditor may not receive payment. Consequently, creditors may be less inclined to pursue legal action against a Wyoming Close LLC.
Wyoming is the most blockchain-friendly state
Wyoming recently enacted 13 blockchain-friendly laws aimed at fostering innovation and attracting capital, jobs, and revenue to the state. As the first state to clarify the treatment of digital assets under existing commercial laws, Wyoming has created a comprehensive legal framework for blockchain technology, which has become a magnet for tech startups and attracted an influx of fintech-based LLCs.
Among other things, these newly enacted blockchain laws recognize property rights for digital asset owners, establish a fintech sandbox that provides financial innovators with three years of protection from existing regulations, authorize basic banking services for blockchain-based businesses, grant cryptocurrencies the super-negotiability rules of money, and enable smart contracts.
Individuals, startups, and blockchain companies can benefit from the protections of Wyoming’s crypto-friendly laws by forming a Wyoming LLC. This action locates the LLC’s digital assets in Wyoming and can reduce tax liabilities, as digital assets are exempt from state property taxes. While other states are also developing blockchain-friendly laws, Wyoming has clearly seized the first-mover advantage in the digital asset space and has earned the nickname “the Delaware of digital asset law.”
Wyoming has significantly lower taxes for both business owners and private income
Wyoming stands out for its absence of state personal income tax, corporate income tax, franchise tax, and, as previously mentioned, property tax for digital assets. Consequently, numerous small business proprietors may discover that Wyoming presents significantly more advantageous avenues for reducing tax burdens.
Wyoming has fewer fees associated with incorporating and maintaining an LLC
Many small business owners and entrepreneurs operate on tight budgets. Consequently, choosing to incorporate in Wyoming can be a strategic move to alleviate financial burdens. Wyoming boasts some of the nation’s most affordable administrative costs for filing and maintaining an LLC. The initial filing fee is $100, and the annual maintenance fee is typically around $60 for LLCs with assets under $250,000. For LLCs with assets over $250,000 and located in the state, the fee is calculated at $0.0002 per dollar of assets.
Wyoming requires less paperwork and identifying information
Incorporating your LLC in Wyoming involves significantly less paperwork compared to many other states. While an operating agreement is advisable, it’s not mandatory by Wyoming law. Annual reports in Wyoming are concise, typically confirming only the LLC name and registered agent information. Moreover, there’s no requirement to submit an initial list of LLC members and officers during the registration process. These streamlined procedures make it easier for business owners to manage their responsibilities, particularly in the early stages post-incorporation. Wyoming also offers a unique feature called ‘lifetime proxy,’ enabling owners to confidentially delegate their voting rights to a chosen individual, further enhancing their anonymity.
Wyoming allows easy domestication
Transferring an LLC to Wyoming from another state is straightforward. Utilizing the continuance process, an existing LLC can maintain its original formation date, preserving the advantages linked with longevity and uninterrupted operation. Unlike many other jurisdictions that necessitate the creation of a new corporate entity, Wyoming simplifies the process for business owners relocating or recognizing the superior benefits of incorporating in Wyoming compared to their current state.
Disadvantages of a Wyoming LLC
Incorporating your LLC in Wyoming offers numerous advantages, particularly for small business owners, family businesses, and technology startups seeking to reduce operating costs while ensuring robust asset and liability protection. However, one drawback, especially for entrepreneurs seeking to form larger or riskier LLCs, is Wyoming’s less mature corporate laws and legal framework compared to Delaware’s well-established system.
Depending on your business needs, you’ll need to evaluate whether the cost savings of a Wyoming LLC outweigh the predictability and stability offered by a Delaware LLC.
Do you have any other questions?
Choosing the right state for your LLC is a critical decision that can impact your business operations, tax obligations, and long-term success. If you have additional questions about forming an LLC in Delaware, Wyoming, or somewhere else – or if you need further guidance on legal, financial, or operational matters don’t hesitate to ask.
Whether you’re curious about:
- Comparing costs and filing requirements,
- Understanding tax implications,
- The process for transferring an existing LLC to another state, or
- Industry-specific considerations for your business,
We’re here to help. Feel free to reach out with any questions or concerns, no matter how big or small. Your success is our priority!
For more details, check out the Startxpress Help Center and Blog. If you need assistance, contact us at support@startxpress.io!
Related Articles
- What is an EIN?
- Why do tech startups incorporate in Delaware?
- What Is the Best State to Form Your LLC In?
- What Tax Compliances are required for me?
- Do I need an ITIN to apply for a credit card?
Was this helpful?
0 / 0